This is the third “Stories Behind…” book I have on my bookshelf, but the first I actually sat down to read the whole way through (the others I hit the songs I was interested in). It was very interesting. I expected it to be more of a historical approach, covering the biographies of the composers and the history of the individual songs. Instead, some of the songs had more of a devotional lean.
Some of the songs I was familiar with the composers, but I enjoyed learning about so many more! In some ways, it felt like the author “Christianized” a few of the composers who maybe didn’t live a godly lifestyle, but the song they wrote is popularized in Christian circles.
A few times, things also seemed a bit ecumenical or extrabiblical (especially since it’s dealing with songs about heaven). They were just small thoughts sprinkled throughout the book, but enough to where I was going, “Okay, the Bible doesn’t exactly say this…” (but then and again, a few of the songs that were covered in this book are songs I don’t particularly care for, because their words don’t line up exactly with Scripture). This wasn’t for the entirety of the book, just portions of it.
I think I would have preferred if the book had stuck more to the basic facts instead of presenting each song with a glorified story, but I realize this is just me as a history nerd.
*I received this book from the publishers and provided my honest review*
Purchase on Amazon
Tag: Music
Are You Getting Back into Music Practice? (or do you have a student who is?)
My Jesus, I Love Thee | Music Video
Video Lesson Openings!
O Holy Night | Violin and Piano
Go Tell it on the Mountain | Violin Solo
Music Sale for Black Friday!
First ever physical sale at With a Joyful Noise!! I have been behind in promoting new releases, so there are a couple of books out that I’ve not announced yet on the site or social media. But, these are included in the sale! You can get the books for 20% off, CDs for 10% off.
Angels We Have Heard on High | Piano/Violin Duet
I absolutely love the “Glo-o-o-o-o-ria” in “Angels we Have Heard on High!” When my sister/student requested this one for recital, I was more than happy to oblige her and arrange it for piano and violin.
What is your favorite element of a Christmas carol?
![]() |
| Sheet music available at With a Joyful Noise |
Christmas CD Now Ready!
Hopping in briefly this evening because I just made the first order of “Christmas is a Gift” CDs!! That means they’ll be ready for me to ship to you toward the end of November!
If you’d like a copy, you may sign up here.






